Meep! I think I pretty much agree with your sum-up of Phantom--they also cut out the trio in the graveyard and made it a duet. Musically, I think the Masquerade was THE best part---that and the opening. I love the way they snapped it from black and white and worn to full color and absolutely rich in decorum and life.

I have to admit though, I was pretty impressed by Minnie Driver...I never knew she could pull off Carlotta so well.